There’s a subtle art to dressing for an occasion that requires more than a t-shirt but less than a suit. You know the one: “smart casual” at a garden party, or that first date where you want to look like you tried, but not too hard. For this sartorial minefield, we present the Howler Brothers Ranchero Polo ($75), the gentleman’s secret weapon. It’s a shirt that subtly enters the room with a straightforward, single-button pocket design, lulling onlookers into a false sense of security. But then, you turn around, and the game is changed.

This isn’t your average golf course polo. Made from a lightweight and ultra-soft 100% ring-spun cotton, it feels so good you might forget you’re even wearing a collar. But the real star of the show is the western yokes, complete with subtle chainstitch embroidery and secured with classy pearl snaps instead of those fiddly buttons. It’s the kind of detail that says you have a certain je ne sais quoi, or at least, you’ve decided to stop dressing like a teenager. Plus, the straight hem with side vents is a godsend for anyone who considers tucking in a polo a federal crime. For a cool $75, you’re not just buying a shirt, you’re polishing up your style game.

The Ranchero Polo is the perfect gift for the man who needs to level up his casual wear without a fuss. It’s a regular fit that’s effortlessly comfortable and untucked-ready. It’s the shirt that works for a backyard barbecue, a casual office day, or a low-key Friday night—providing just the right amount of cowboy bravado to make an impression without having to wear a hat.