Let’s face it, gentlemen, your closet is probably overflowing with shirts that are “just fine.” But “just fine” never won any awards, did it? Enter the Taylor Stitch Jack Shirt in Indigo Plaid ($132), here to rescue your sartorial soul from the clutches of mediocrity.

At first glance, it might look like a mere button-down. Oh, but you’d be delightfully wrong. This isn’t just any shirt; it’s a meticulously crafted garment with a secret life. Made from 100% organic cotton and boasting double-needle felled construction, this shirt is built like a tank, but wears like a dream.

It’s pre-shrunk, so no awkward post-laundry surprises, and the indigo dye promises to fade “beautifully over time” – meaning it’ll look even better as you rack up adventures (or just binge-watch TV).

A quick heads-up: being indigo-dyed, it has a tendency to “crock,” which is a fancy way of saying it might share its charming blue hue with lighter fabrics. So, maybe don’t wear it while performing impromptu surgery on a polar bear. But embrace the crocking, embrace the fades, and embrace the fact that you’ve just found your new favorite shirt. It’s time to upgrade from “just fine” to “damn fine.”